Es6: Guénon’s Traditionalism

Es6: Guénon’s Traditionalism

- in Esotericism
0

1. The first major figure in Traditionalism was René Guénon (1886-1951), a French esotericist, metaphysician and voluminous author. Early on he developed an interest in the occult and began to read works of various spiritual traditions – Buddhism, Hinduism, Sufism, Taoism. In 1912 he embraced Sufism adopted the name Abd al-Wahid Yahya and stayed in Egypt for some years: he studied and practiced Sufism, wrote articles and gained a good reputation in the intellectual community there. In 1920 he returned to France and embarked on writing and promoting the idea of Tradition – or “perennial philosophy” (Philosophia Perenialis/Prisca, in academic parlance) which teaches that all genuine religions and philosophical systems had their origin in an ancient unified tradition, aspects of which are still preserved in myths and other systems or fragments of teachings, the inner meaning of which the Modern West has forgotten.

2. In 1908 when he was a young seeker in Paris, during a séance of automatic writing held by Marinists (yet another occult/metaphysical group) “the spirit of Jacques de Molay, last Grand Master of the Templars (burned on the stake on an island in the river Seine in Paris, in September 1314), demanded that the Order of the Templars be revived with twenty-one-year-old Guėnon as its head. (So, J. Godwin 2011, Atlantis and the Cycles of Time… ch.6). This was done [but soon failed] and séances were held during which questions were asked on all kinds of subjects – the Archéomètre system of occultist Saint Yves, symbolism of letters and numbers, colours and corresponding musical notes, the “primordial” [but non-existent] language Vattan or Watan, different states of being and so on. Godwin gives a long list of “replies”:

Total duration of humanity 12,882 x 7 = ca 90.000 years.

The earth is not the only planet on which humans live.

White race appeared at 62.500 BCE.

Yellow race came from the planet Venus (hence “Sons of Heaven”)!

All these and others are related to Atlantean lore and theosophical “revelations”, which flourished in the second half of the 19th century.

I doubt if much of all this really interested Guėnon. He certainly criticised vehemently the Theosophical Society and its activities publishing a book on the subject in later years. In fact, he condemned many spiritual organisations (Masons, Martinists, Theosophists and so on) and declared that there was no point at all in trying to revive the ancient cultures of Egypt, Babylon, the Celts and others.

On the other hand, he joined the Gnostic Church of France and tried to setup a new Masonic Lodge run on the principles of the Ancient Tradition, as he understood and preached it.

3. In the earlier paper Es2, in section §5, Guénon defended Ossendowski’s report on [non-existent] Agartha which was given to him in Mongolia and was a significant section of his book Beasts, Men and Gods (1922) – a fraudulent fantasy, as we saw. Here too §2, you see the absurdities he was willing to support.

Then, in 1927, Guénon produced (after considerable research) his own Roi du Monde (King of the World), in which he repeats his support of Ossendowiski and amplifies many motifs, symbols and interconnections. Before examining the main points in Guénon’s book, I focus on the motif of the Four Ages which pre-occupies him in other publications as well.

In note 2 of chapter 8 (“The supreme center concealed during the Kali-Yuga”), he states that a manvantara, “an era of a Manu, [is] also called Mahā-yuga”. This is an incomprehensible error (and I have seen it in another one of his books but no longer remember which one). The Mahā-yuga which contains the 4 yugas (Kṛta or Sat, Tretā, Dvāpara and Kali) is, in fact, a period within the Manvantara, which has 71 Mahāyugas!

This error might perhaps be forgiven. But then Guénon actually proceeds in various other publications to correct the texts of the agelong Indic tradition which assign hundreds of thousands and millions of years to these Ages. The 4 Ages make up one mahāyuga and seventy-one (71) mahāyugas make up one manvantara. Fourteen (14) manvantaras make up one kalpa and this is one Day of creator-god Brahmā which is the duration of the existence of our Universe, to be absorbed back for a Night of equal duration! (Details will be found in many texts and secondary books: the epic Mahabharata 12.231, Manusmŗti 1.65-86, Sūryasiddhānta ch 1, Viṣṇu–purāṇa and others).

Without going into details, the native texts give for Kaliyuga 432.000 years, for Dvāpara 864.000, for Tretā 1.296.000 and for Sat 1.728.000. A mahāyuga lasts 4.320.000, a manvāntara 71 times that and a Kalpa 14 times the manvantara.

Guėnon like many another occultist accepts the full scheme of the Ages (or Aeons, as others call them) and the proportionate lengths (1:2:3:4, starting with Kaliyuga) and connects them with the Hesiodic Iron, Bronze, Silver and Golden Ages (in Works & Days). And, although as a traditionalist he has very great respect for such traditional (especially Indic) lore, here he has a difficulty: the numbers are too big, he thinks, the ages much too long. Judging by his writings, I think he was so concerned with Manu being in the spiritual plane the Pontifex Maximus (the Supreme political and religious leader of the entire manvantara), and so being an example for human leadership and authority in our mundane doings, that he missed the totality of the universal picture.

So, he decided that the ancient Indians added the zeros to conceal the real durations and confuse us. And so, he subtracted the zeros. But then the number 432 is ludicrously small for the whole Age. So, he found a factor of 15 and multiplied the numbers (without the zeros)! Thus, he obtained 6.480 for the kali or Iron age, 12.960 for Dvāpara or Bronze age, 19.440 for Tretā or Silver age and 25.920 for the Sat or Golden age. And he was happy with a mahāyuga (or manvantara in his own terms) of 64.800 years (instead of the Indic traditional 4.320.000)!

Except that, even if you are not a “traditionalist”, you don’t mess about in this manner with such ancient texts.

4. Back to The King of the World, Ossendowski’s Agartha and Guėnon’s own ramifications and explanations.

Guénon dismisses rather contemptuously in the first chapter Jacolliot, who first wrote of Agartha, and passes on to Ferdinand Ossendowski. He does not think that FO plagiarises from Saint Yves (or others) because, he writes, “We know through other sources, independent of the evidence offered by Ossendowiski himself, that stories of this kind are current in Mongolia and throughout Central Asia”.

But he offers no other sources whatever! Why not? Because there are none! He seems satisfied with certain minor differences: e.g. the evidence in Saint Yves is from the story of one lambalus by Diodorus of Sicily, whereas FO has a Buddhist monk; or writing Agarthi and not Agartha; etc. He also accepts that the origin of Gypsies is Agartha as in FO, although there is ample evidence that they came to Europe via Iran moving out of India (as their language indicates by its connection to Sanskrit) in the early centuries of the Common Era.

Following Saint Yves, he thinks this centre, Agartha, underground somewhere, perhaps in the Gobi Desert, is now the seat of the Solar Dynasty (sūrya-vaṃsa), successor to Ayodhyā in ancient India, capital of Rāma’s kingdom and other glorious monarchs going back to Manu (the 7th of the 14 archons of manvantaras, [and going further back to Brahmā, the Creator-God and, in some texts, to Viṣṇu). Now why the Solar Dynasty with an unnamed king other than the Brah(m)atma, should end up underground is an unexplained and very strange story.

5. In the same chapter Guénon opines that “initiates of Agartha are ativarṇa, i.e. “above or beyond caste”. But he gives no real information what the Hindu initiations were in fact. And I should make a point here, that the term “Hindu” is from British colonialism. It covers a multitude of religious sects worshipping Ṥiva (and Pārvatī), Vișṇu (and Lakṣmī), Rama (and Sitā), Kŗṣna, Kubera, Ganeśa etc., but also philosophical-psychological schools or traditions (Vedānta, Yoga, Sāmkhya etc.). There is no autonomous or independent “Hinduism” as such, as many authors, for the sake of convenience perhaps, are fond of writing.

Writing about Brahmin and Kshatriya in chapter 2, he gives in note 6 an explanation saying that European medieval classes correspond, the clergy to brahmins, the nobility to kshatriyas, the third estate (= merchants and producers) to Vaishyas and the serfs to Shūdras. This is quite right but the division into castes, or classes or estates, concerns, in fact, the 4 essential functions to be carried out in any society or Polity: a) good spiritual and ethical guidance ensuring prosperity and happiness; b) good government ensuring safety, justice, property; c) production, primary (food stuffs and drink) and secondary (industry and technology) and trading; d) unskilled work and service.

6. In ch. 5 of The King of the World Guénon deals with the “Symbolism of the Grail” and writes in the beginning: “All traditions allude to something that from a certain time become[s] lost or hidden, such as the Soma of the Hindus and the Persian Haoma or ‘draught of the immortality’ these latter having a precise and very direct connection with the Grail, which was said to be the sacred chalice that contained the blood of Christ – another ‘draught of immortality’. Elsewhere the symbolism is different, as, for instance, among the Jews, where it is the pronunciation of the full divine Name that has been lost…”

Now, it is obvious that the Grail is a container whereas the Soma or Haoma is a draught, a liquid or the plant from which the drink was extracted. So, the two are not parallel. Then, the Soma/Haoma drink existed many centuries before Christ and the Christian theologians who followed. And it would be absurd to hold that Christ’s blood was still contained in the Grail 1.100 years after Christ (in the medieval Grail romances)! As for “the full divine Name” – this was not lost in the Jewish tradition but it was prohibited for the faithful Jews to utter it! Otherwise, both “I am” and “Yahweh” were known and not lost. How can he err to such an extent?

Then he continues: It is said that the Holy Grail is the chalice that served at the Last Supper [and Christ drank from it] and in which Joseph of Arimathea collected the blood and water flowing from the wound in Christ’s side, opened by the lance of the centurion Longinus. According to legend this chalice was carried to England by Joseph of Arimathea and Nicodemus, indicating a link between the Celtic tradition and Christianity. (…) [E]qually worth noting is its frequent association with the lance [of the centurion].

And in note 4 he explains that “the symbolism of the lance is often related to the World Axis” in that “the blood dripping from the lance has the same significance as the dew falling from the Tree of Life”! In note 3 he has linked the two figures of Joseph and Nicodemus with the royal and sacerdotal powers as exhibited by Arthur and Merlin! But, please note that phrases like “it is said” and “according to legend” are in reality meaningless when no sources at all are given!

Be that as it may, Guénon continues unabashed: The essential significance of the Grail is perhaps shown most clearly by what is said of its origin: it is supposed to have been fashioned by angels from the emerald that dropped from Lucifer’s forehead at the time of his fall. This emerald rather strikingly calls to mind the urṇā or frontal pearl which in Hindu symbolism (and subsequently adopted by Buddhism) often takes the place of the third eye of Shiva representing what can be called the ‘sense of eternity’. It is said also that the Grail had been entrusted to Adam in the Terrestrial Paradise but that after his fall he lost it in turn, for he was not allowed to take it when he was driven from Eden.

So, the Grail is pre-Christian, fashioned in heaven by angels from an emerald that fell from Lucifer’s crown, before the appearance of Adam(!), Lucifer being “the angel of the Crown” (in note 5)! But “the legend does not record where and by whom the Grail was preserved until the time of Christ” but the “Druids had a role”! In fact, again, no sources at all are cited for these extraordinary fantasies presented as “tradition”.

As for the pearl that takes the place of Shiva’s third eye – the Sanskrit word urṇā/ūrṇā denotes, in fact, (not a pearl but) a thread (woolen, usually) and secondarily the circle of hair which some people have between eyebrows. Shiva uses his “third eye” (not in the sense of immortality but) to focus on and burn sin or anything threatening or troublesome, like Kāma, the god of eros or desire when he tried to distract him from his meditation!

7 But all this learning is utterly imaginary made up of fantasies in the French, English and German romances of the late 12th and early 13th centuries. There may have been influences from Welsh folk poems or tales as some writers attempt to show in the 19th and 20th centuries, but this is not certain. There is very little substantially historical about the Adventures of the Holy Grail and Arthur’s Knights of the Round Table in them.

This so called “tradition” begins clearly with the Frenchman Chrétien de Troys’s unfinished poem Perceval, le Conte du Graal (1180 – 1190 The Story of the Grail) followed by the Four Continuations (1190-1210), which purport to complete – with varied details – Chrétien’s unfinished tale. Now, the grail (graal, in the Old French original) is not a sacred cup or chalice but a large, glittering bejeweled dish for serving food and has not the importance of other items like the sword which the lame nobleman (= the Fisher King) gives to Perceval before the feast or the blood-dripping lance paraded emphatically during the feast.

Indeed, as Guénon writes, “According to legend this chalice was carried to England by Joseph of Arimathea and Nicodemus, indicating a link between the Celtic tradition and Christianity”, but this “legend” was invented in the 13th cent, by the Burgundian writer Robert de Boron in a trilogy, of which only Joseph of Arimathea and a fragment of Merlin survived, but some contemporary author of de Boron wrote the full story, so we have the (probable?) version of it, while the third, Perceval, has been completely lost. De Boron has Joseph come to Britain bringing the Holy Chalice, the cup which Christ used in the Last Supper, which was given to him by Pontius Pilate (!) and used later by him to collect the blood of Christ flowing from the wound inflicted by the centurion’s lance!

Now, the advent of Joseph of Arimathea in Britain (and later to Glastonbury) is sheer invention while the connection is found in an Apocryphal text of the 2nd cent, CE, Gospel of Nicodemus, part of which is known as the Acts of Pilate. In this text, we do find Joseph but no grail at all! Other writers accepting the premises of the Arthurian narratives, modified or amplified this tale introducing more fanciful details to make it more interesting. Thus, in a German version, Wolfram von Eschenbach’s Parzival, the grail is a miraculous stone called lapsis exillis and the Grail knights of the King are called templeise (= templars!). The emerald which fell from Lucifer’s crown and from which, long before the birth of Christ in human form, the angels fashioned the Holy Grail, according to Guénon, is also found in Parzival!

So, all this legendary material appears for the first time in these medieval romances which became the breeding ground of “legend” and “tradition”. Guénon must have known much of this lore since a large part of the literature was in Old French. However, he preferred to regard it all as sacred traditional material and fit it into his feverish fantasies, instead of sifting it through a critical historical apparatus, as good scholars do.

8. Guénon went back to Egypt eventually and stayed with the Islamic religion or, more precisely, the Sufis in Cairo. He married there and had children. I assume he practiced whatever these Sufis practise. But there is nothing in his publications to show that he has a real experience of the Unity of Being which is the Ultimate Reality of genuine esotericism.

His writings show a vast polymathy, as in The King of the World where, in chapter after chapter, is woven a complex and tiresome web of affinities and interconnections, but has only a very limited intellectual value. For example in the 4th chapter we read: “The stone representing the Omphalos could take the form of a pillar like the stone of Jacob, and it is quite probable that among the Celtic people certain ‘menhirs’ had the same significance; and the oracles were uttered close by these stones, as at Delphi, which is easily explained by the fact that they were considered to be the dwelling place of the divinity, the ‘House of God’ being moreover quite naturally identified with the ‘Center of the World’. The Omphalos could also be represented in the form of a cone, like the black stone of Cybele, or an ovoid, the cone recalling the sacred mountain. Symbol of the ‘Pole’ or ‘World Axis’, and the ovoid form relating directly to mother, very important, symbol, the ‘World Egg’”.

In note 14 are added several more connections. The entire book is full of such webs of allusions

9. Guénon’s scholarship jumps here and there in a very wide area but has no depth. He should have known that the Sufi branch of Islam was, in some of its practices, influenced by Vedic lore and yogic exercises. If he had delved more deeply and had asked expert orientalists, he would have found out, even in his own times, that A. Von Kremer refers in his study of Islamic Civilisation (1873) to a version of the Indic Kāmarūpa “Seed Syllables” or “Forms of Desire”, mentioned for its breathing and other yogic exercises in a 14th century Persian Encyclopedia. Also, that the Indic Amŗta Kunda “Pool of Nectar” (again with breathing, meditative and other yogic practices) was translated into Persian in 1210 (first in Bengali then into Arabic and Turkish) and then became a “best-seller” in Muslim spiritual circles.

10. In his earlier book The Crisis of the Modern World (Le crise du Monde Moderne1927, transl. by A Osborne, 1942, Luzac, London) Guénon writes that we are in “the last phase of the Kali yuga, the darkest period of the ‘dark age’ the state of dissolution from which it is impossible to emerge otherwise than by a cataclysm” (p18) and live in chaotic conditions. Later on, he bemoans the loss of true Aristocracy (the power of the elite with authority deriving from intellectual superiority: pp. 77-8). He sees only “one way out of the chaos, in the social domain as in all others: the restoration of intellectuality, which would result in the formation once more of an elite” (emphasis in the original).

I point out two things here. a) I showed in section §3 above that he re-arranged the 4 Ages or Indic yugas distorting the original periods of duration so that the whole scheme fitted with his own notions. b) The Kali-yuga shows no signs of ending – though some think that it did end and we are now in the Golden Age or Sad-yuga! The Vedic scheme says we are at the very beginning – and God knows what will follow in 200 or 50 years!

Finally, we should note that while Guénon‘s writings exhibit enormous learning (much discussion of ideas and tiresome parades of affinities and of explanations of symbols in many traditions, often wrong as we have seen), there is not a single mention in his writings of an experience of his own regarding the expansion of consciousness and perception of the Oneness of everything which is the basic and central point of the practice of genuine esotericism and which would characterize the true aristocrat (of spirit) in the perennial Tradition. Note the following description of a modern mystic, Krishnamurti:

The valley was cool, pleasant and so intensely alive. The heavy electric cables on pylons seemed a part of that unsophisticated world. The mountains with their snow seemed so close and delicate. The goats were bleating to be milked. Quite unexpectedly all this extravagant beauty, colour, the hills, the rich earth, the intense valley – all this was within one. It wasn’t within one. One’s own heart and brain were so completely open, without the barrier of time and space, so empty of thought and feeling, that there was only that beauty, without sound or form. It was there and everything else ceased to be. The immensity of this love, with beauty and death, was there filling the valley and one’s whole being which was the valley. (p. 86, Krishnamurti’s Notebook 1976/1978 Perennial Library Edition).

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *